Santa Barbara is known for its scenic beauty, sun-soaked beaches, and, of course, a vibrant dining scene that rivals much larger cities. When it comes to Italian cuisine, the city offers a selection of authentic spots that cater to every taste. From traditional pasta to innovative Neapolitan-style pizzas, here are the top 10 best Italian restaurants in Santa Barbara that bring a taste of Italy to the California coast.
1. Via Maestra 42
Located in the heart of Santa Barbara, Via Maestra 42 is a charming Italian bistro that has been serving locals for years. Known for its intimate setting, this spot offers classic Italian dishes crafted with imported ingredients and homemade pasta. The lasagna, osso buco, and their selection of daily specials have earned a loyal following, and their gelato and Italian pastries make for a perfect finish to any meal.
Must-Try: Their lasagna is renowned, and don’t miss out on their creamy panna cotta for dessert.
2. Ca’ Dario Ristorante
Ca’ Dario has long been one of Santa Barbara’s most celebrated Italian restaurants. With Chef Dario Furlati at the helm, this upscale eatery combines authentic Italian flavors with a California twist. Known for its sophisticated ambiance and an extensive wine list, Ca’ Dario’s dishes, like the pasta alla carbonara and veal piccata, showcase the finest ingredients and culinary craftsmanship.
Must-Try: The gnocchi with truffle sauce is a crowd favorite and pairs wonderfully with a glass of Chianti.
3. Olio e Limone Ristorante
Olio e Limone Ristorante brings a touch of Sicily to Santa Barbara with its refined yet warm atmosphere. This restaurant is known for its creative Italian dishes that blend fresh California produce with Italian flair. From house-made pastas to savory seafood dishes, Olio e Limone is perfect for a romantic evening or an upscale family dinner.
Must-Try: Try the tagliatelle with white truffle oil for a decadent treat.
4. Olio Pizzeria
For a more casual dining experience, Olio Pizzeria—adjacent to Olio e Limone—serves up some of the best pizzas in town. Known for its Neapolitan-style pizza with a thin, crispy crust and a selection of imported Italian toppings, Olio Pizzeria is perfect for a quick bite or a relaxed meal with friends. The extensive selection of pizzas is complemented by an impressive wine and beer list.
Must-Try: The Margherita pizza is simple but classic, and the burrata is a must-have appetizer.
5. Toma Restaurant and Bar
Toma, overlooking the waterfront, combines Italian and Mediterranean influences in a stunning location. Their seasonal menu highlights fresh, local ingredients and pairs them with classic Italian recipes. Toma’s atmosphere is cozy and romantic, making it a popular choice for date nights. The seafood risotto and handmade pastas are just a few of the highlights on the menu.
Must-Try: The wild mushroom risotto is packed with flavor, and the grilled octopus starter is also a hit.
6. Arnoldi’s Café
Arnoldi’s Café is Santa Barbara’s oldest Italian restaurant, known for its old-world charm and bocce ball court. This family-owned establishment offers a cozy, casual atmosphere and generous portions of classic Italian comfort food. With over 80 years of history, Arnoldi’s is beloved for its authentic flavors and welcoming vibe.
Must-Try: The spaghetti Bolognese and calamari steak are popular among regulars, and the tiramisu is a great finish to the meal.
7. Petrini’s (For Lasagna Lovers)
Petrini’s is a relaxed, family-friendly spot known for its standout lasagna and warm ambiance. This restaurant brings traditional Italian flavors to the table, with a focus on hearty dishes like pizzas, pastas, and baked specialties. Petrini’s lasagna, with its layers of rich sauce, cheese, and noodles, is often considered one of the best in town.
Must-Try: Don’t leave without trying the lasagna—it’s the star of the menu and loved by locals.
8. Bettina in Montecito
For pizza enthusiasts, Bettina in Montecito is the place to be. Located in the Montecito Country Mart, Bettina specializes in artisanal, wood-fired pizzas that bring a taste of Naples to California. The dough is fermented for 24 hours, resulting in a perfectly chewy crust, and topped with a curated selection of high-quality ingredients. It’s a perfect spot for a relaxed lunch or a casual dinner.
Must-Try: The Margherita pizza and their house-made burrata are must-orders.
9. Mizza
Mizza is a modern Italian restaurant located in the heart of Santa Barbara. With a stylish yet relaxed vibe, Mizza serves up fresh Italian-inspired dishes that reflect California’s local ingredients. The pizza and pasta options are plentiful, and the restaurant’s open kitchen adds a fun, lively atmosphere.
Must-Try: The clam and garlic pizza and pasta alla vodka are both delicious, offering a fresh twist on Italian classics.
10. Aperitivo
Rounding out the list is Aperitivo, a delightful wine bar with a selection of Italian small plates. Aperitivo offers a more casual, European-style experience, perfect for light bites and a glass of Italian wine. The menu features bruschetta, cured meats, cheeses, and antipasti, making it a great spot for an afternoon snack or a pre-dinner drink.
Must-Try: The charcuterie boards are artfully presented and pair perfectly with their extensive Italian wine selection.
Santa Barbara’s Italian dining scene is a journey through the diverse regions of Italy, from rich pastas and pizzas to fresh seafood and rustic dishes. Whether you’re looking for a casual pizzeria or an elegant dining experience, these top Italian restaurants offer something for every Italian food lover in town.
